What on Earth Happened to NIO?

Not too long ago, Nio (NYSE: NIO) seemed poised to post a breakout fourth quarter.

The EV manufacturer from China experienced significant delivery growth thanks to their newly introduced brand, Onvo, which started contributing to sales towards the end of 2024. The company performed well during the third quarter as they enhanced their vehicle profit margins despite difficult market conditions. Additionally, they unveiled another brand called Firefly, aimed at further increasing revenue through 2025.

Where should you put your $1,000 investment at this moment? Our analyst team just revealed what they believe are the 10 best stocks to buy right now. Learn More »

However, Q4 fell short of expectations for both Wall Street analysts and everyday investors. What went wrong?

Driving growth

One of the largest reasons to buy into Nio's vision was that the previously mentioned new brands are set to drive deliveries higher and thus generate strong revenue growth. While part of that worked according to plan, it's also true that it didn't drive top-line growth analysts expected during the fourth quarter.

In Q4, vehicle deliveries checked in at 72,689. That figure breaks down into 52,760 vehicles from its premium Nio brand and the remaining 19,929 vehicles from its family-oriented smart EV brand, Onvo. The result was a solid 45% gain over the prior year's Q4 and a healthy 17.5% jump from 2024's Q3.

Nevertheless, this expansion in vehicle deliveries did not meet investor expectations for boosting the top line. The total revenue surged by 15.2% compared to the previous year and rose by 5.5% from the third quarter of 2024. This indicates that although the company is broadening its sales base, China—currently Nio’s main marketplace—is embroiled in an extremely fierce pricing battle where rivals are drastically cutting their prices to hold onto their market positions.

Although the overall revenue stayed slow relative to the company’s progress in deliveries, there is an encouraging aspect within these figures. In the fourth quarter, the automotive profit margin stood at 13.1%, up from 11.9% recorded in the corresponding period of the previous year and matching the levels seen in the third quarter of 2024. This indicates that despite the Chinese electric-vehicle manufacturer needing to become more aggressive with prices, they managed to cut expenses sufficiently to protect their profit margins.

To sum up, Nio is broadening its market presence via new product releases while also reducing expenses to protect its profit margins. So, why didn’t Wall Street approve of this strategy?

What gives?

Nio’s stock price was steadily climbing throughout March until the company was about to release its Q4 financials. When the quarterly figures came out, they fell short of analyst expectations both at the high end and low end of projections. However, the primary factor causing the negative sentiment seems to be the conservative forecast provided by the company for Q1 of 2025.

Nio now anticipates delivering around 43,000 vehicles in Q1, with revenues expected to be approximately 12.9 billion yuan ($1.8 billion). This falls significantly short of analyst expectations, who were looking for roughly 65,000 vehicles and 17.8 billion yuan ($2.45 billion). The conservative first-quarter forecast has exacerbated concerns surrounding the Chinese electric vehicle company’s ability to achieve sustained profitability.

A significant concern for investors is this unaddressed problem. While Nio is making substantial efforts to reduce expenses in order to keep profit margins stable, they continue to invest heavily in their resource-demanding battery-swapping infrastructure. However, the financial losses stemming from this initiative are anticipated not to decrease anytime soon.

What it all means

Even though Nio fell short of predictions and provided sluggish first-quarter forecasts, their fourth quarter wasn’t entirely disappointing. Nonetheless, it’s evident that they must adapt strategies to cope with China’s electric-vehicle pricing competition. To stay competitive, Nio needs to introduce updated models, launch new vehicles, and find alternative methods for boosting income from their current offerings—eschewing the extreme discounting tactics employed by certain rivals.

Should the firm’s income expansion manage to align more with its robust vehicle output increase, all while persistently reducing expenses to uphold profit margins, then 2025 could be key. Still in the process of getting set for what promises to be a robust year for the corporation. That being said, numerous queries remain regarding the firm's battery-swapping initiative, its international expansion particularly into Europe where it will encounter tariffs, as well as its slow revenue growth.

Management remains optimistic about reaching profitability in Q4 of 2025, yet achieving this may require more than just doubling their projected sales figures. They will likely need to explore additional strategies to counteract the intense pricing competition that shows no signs of subsiding soon.

Is it a good idea to put $1,000 into Nio at this moment?

Before purchasing shares of Nio, keep this in mind:

The Motley Fool Stock Advisor The analyst team has just pinpointed what they think could be the 10 best stocks For investors looking to purchase now... Nio was not among them. The 10 stocks that were selected have the potential to generate substantial gains over the next few years.

Consider when Nvidia created this list on April 15, 2005... should you have invested $1,000 following our suggestion, you’d have $578,035 !*

Now, it’s worth noting Stock Advisor 's overall average return is 730% — significantly outperforming the market by a large margin compared to 147% For the S&P 500. Don’t miss the most recent top 10 list, which becomes accessible upon joining. Stock Advisor .

See the 10 stocks »

*Stock Advisor returns as of April 1, 2025

Daniel Miller The Motley Fool does not hold shares in any of the companies mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. disclosure policy .